How to Resolve 500 Internal Server Errors Caused by Outdated or Incompatible WordPress Plugins — Debugging + Rollback Steps

By
Issabela Garcia
-
0
17

You’re cruising through your WordPress site, proud of how smooth everything looks… and then BAM! A wild 500 Internal Server Error appears out of nowhere. Panic mode? Not necessary. Especially when outdated or incompatible plugins are usually the sneaky culprits. Let’s break this down like a good mystery—simple, fun, and step-by-step.

TLDR;

A 500 Internal Server Error often means a plugin has gone rogue. It’s usually caused by bad code, versions that don’t play nice, or recent updates. Try disabling plugins one by one, and if you find the bad one, roll it back to an older version. Keep things backed up, and you’ll be the hero of your own WordPress story.

What is a 500 Internal Server Error?

This error is like a shrug from your server. It says, “Something’s wrong, but I’m not telling you what.” 😅

Common causes:

  • Plugin conflicts
  • Incompatible plugin versions
  • Corrupted plugin files
  • PHP version mismatch

Today, our villain is outdated or incompatible plugins. So, let’s become WordPress detectives and solve this mystery.

Step 1: Detect the Problem Plugin

You usually can’t access your dashboard when this error hits. But don’t worry — FTP is your best friend right now.

Here’s what to do:

  1. Use an FTP client (like FileZilla) or access File Manager from your hosting panel.
  2. Navigate to wp-content/plugins.
  3. Rename the plugins folder to plugins-deactivated.
  4. Check your site again. Is it working?

If yes, awesome! The problem is one of your plugins. Let’s Sherlock this further.

Find the exact one:

  1. Go back and create a new folder named plugins.
  2. Move your plugins back one at a time from the old folder to the new one.
  3. After each move, refresh your website.

When the error returns, you’ve found the problem plugin. 🎯

Step 2: Roll Back the Plugin

You’ve got the culprit. Now let’s handle them—peacefully. Rolling back means you’re going back to a known good version of the plugin.

Two ways to do it:

Manual Rollback via FTP:

  1. Delete the bad plugin from wp-content/plugins.
  2. Visit the WordPress Plugin Directory.
  3. Search for the plugin and click “Advanced View.”
  4. Scroll to the bottom and download an older version.
  5. Upload the older version via FTP to wp-content/plugins.

Automatic Rollback (When Dashboard Access is Restored):

You can use a helpful plugin like WP Rollback.

  1. Install WP Rollback from the Plugins menu.
  2. Go to Installed Plugins.
  3. Click “Rollback” under the affected plugin.
  4. Select a previous version, then confirm and roll back.

After rolling back, test your site. If it works — congrats! 🥳 Time to party… or maybe just update your plugins safely.

Step 3: Say Hello to Safe Plugin Practices

Prevention is the best backup plan. Here’s how to keep your WordPress world peaceful and 500-error-free.

Follow these golden rules:

  • Back up before updates. Every time. No excuses.
  • Update in batches. Don’t update 10 plugins at once. Do it one or two at a time.
  • Read changelogs. See what’s new and whether it’s compatible with your current setup.
  • Avoid shady plugins. Use trusted sources and well-reviewed plugins only.

Step 4: Check PHP Compatibility

Sometimes it’s not the plugin itself, but the PHP version it’s trying to work with.

You’ll want to:

  1. Log into your hosting cPanel.
  2. Find the option to change PHP version — usually called “Select PHP Version.”
  3. Try rolling back to a slightly older PHP version if your plugin needs it (ex: from 8.2 → 7.4).

*Note:* Too old = insecure. This is just a test. Always use supported PHP versions in the long run.

Step 5: Enable Debug Mode

If you like to get nerdy, this one’s for you. WordPress has a debug mode that shows exactly what’s breaking.

To enable it:

  1. Via FTP, open your wp-config.php file.
  2. Add this line before “That’s all, stop editing!”:
define( 'WP_DEBUG', true );
define( 'WP_DEBUG_LOG', true );
define( 'WP_DEBUG_DISPLAY', false );

This sends errors to a log file in wp-content/debug.log. Open that file and take notes. It often points right to the broken plugin.

Bonus Tip: Site Health Tool

Once your dashboard is working again, head over to Tools → Site Health.

It gives you clues about:

  • Incompatibilities
  • Slow plugins
  • Security risks

Think of it as your WP doctor’s check-up list.

Still Stuck? Try These Extras:

  • Deactivate all plugins, then switch to a default theme. If minimal setup works — plugin is at fault.
  • Contact support. Reach out to your host or plugin developer. Provide the debug log if you have it!
  • Use staging environments. Test everything away from your live site!

Conclusion: No More Panic!

You’ve officially leveled up your WordPress skills. Handling 500 errors isn’t magic—just process and patience. Next time, you won’t run for the hills. Instead, you’ll pop open your FTP app, and say, “I got this.”

So keep your backups close, your plugins updated, and your FTP connection stable. And remember — even servers have bad days. 😄